If a website publishes truthful but secret information about someone, what could likely happen in court?

In cases where a website publishes truthful but secret information about someone, the court may rule that no claim was stated, which aligns with the selected answer. This outcome arises because the legal principle of defamation generally requires the information to be false. Truth is a complete defense in defamation cases, but confidentiality and privacy rights are also crucial factors.

When the information is both truthful and secret, it typically doesn't meet the criteria for defamation or invasion of privacy, depending on jurisdictional laws regarding the disclosure of private facts. If the information is not a matter of public concern and was not obtained in a way that violated any laws, the court may find that the publication does not constitute a legal claim.

Therefore, the plaintiff may not have sufficient grounds to pursue a successful legal action, resulting in a ruling where the court states no valid claim exists, leading to the dismissal of the case.